A favored strategy among members of the Woke Reich is to spread falsehoods about Israel in the name of Christianity.
On March 13, 2026, former Miss California USA Carrie Prejean Boller—now a recent Catholic convert—appeared on Tucker Carlson’s show to attack Israel and Zionism. Although Boller acknowledged that Christians are “supposed to be representing Jesus’s word on Earth,” she proceeded to spread a series of demonstrably false claims about Israel, with Tucker enthusiastically nodding along.
The “Genocide” Claim
The centerpiece of the anti-Israel narrative promoted by Tucker, Boller, and their colleagues is the accusation that Israel is committing “genocide” in Gaza, which they demand “every Christian” speak out against.
The claim has been repeatedly debunked.
President Donald Trump, Vice President J.D. Vance, and other American officials have explicitly stated that Israel’s actions in Gaza do not constitute genocide. Yet Tucker and Boller continue insisting that it is their duty “as Christians” to speak out against this supposed atrocity.
But the claim collapses almost immediately when confronted with publicly available data.
In February 2025, the World Health Organization reported that more than 500,000 children under age 10 were vaccinated against polio in Gaza. That figure alone exceeds the estimated number of children under ten who lived in Gaza when the war began by more than 150,000.
A population supposedly being “genocided,” it seems, has somehow managed to produce an enormous surplus of vaccinated children.
Israel’s battlefield conduct further undermines the claim. The Israel Defense Forces routinely employ extensive civilian warning measures—including phone calls, text messages, leaflet drops, radio broadcasts, and “roof knocking” using non-lethal munitions.
These precautions slow military operations and reduce tactical surprise. If the goal were civilian casualties, such measures would be irrational.
The “70,000 Innocent Civilians”
To sustain the genocide claim, the Woke Reich relies on another false talking point: the assertion that Israel has killed “70,000 innocent civilians” in Gaza.
The sole source for that figure is Hamas.
Hamas casualty reporting has long been recognized as unreliable. Its Ministry of Health classifies all deaths as “civilians,” frequently mislabels adult men as women or children, includes deaths caused by Hamas itself, and even incorporates natural deaths into its totals. Throughout the war, the ministry repeatedly altered, deleted, and reclassified data.
But even if Hamas’s numbers are accepted at face value, the narrative still collapses.
In October 2025, President Trump stated that Hamas had lost approximately 58,000 fighters during the war—about 81 percent of Hamas’s own reported death toll. Under the absurd assumption that every remaining death involved women and children, that would leave roughly 13,667 civilian casualties. If Israel were deliberately targeting civilians, that number would be astonishingly low.
Based on those figures, Israel’s civilian-to-combatant casualty ratio would be approximately 0.24:1. For context, the United Nations estimates the global average civilian-to-combatant death ratio in urban warfare at 9:1.
In other words, the war Tucker calls “genocide” would represent the lowest civilian casualty ratio in the history of modern urban warfare.
Hamas’s death totals also include natural mortality.
Before the war, Gaza averaged roughly 16 natural deaths per day. Over the course of the conflict, that baseline mortality would account for approximately 13,500 deaths unrelated to Israeli military action.
Yet these deaths are routinely folded into Hamas’s casualty counts and then presented on television as evidence of Israeli atrocities.
The Boy Who Was Supposed to Be Dead
Tucker and Boller have repeatedly amplified other false claims about Israeli actions.
In July 2025, Tucker interviewed Anthony Aguilar, who claimed that the Israel Defense Forces had shot and killed a young Gazan boy at a humanitarian aid site.
The story was false. The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation later confirmed that the boy was alive and had been relocated outside Gaza with his mother.
Tucker amplified the claim anyway and never issued a correction.
During her interview, Boller repeated the “heartbreaking” story yet again—solemnly explaining that she was doing so “as a pro-life Christian.”
The “Famine” Myth
Another claim repeated on Tucker’s program is that Israel is deliberately starving Palestinians, something she opposes “as a Christian.”
Here too, the numbers tell a very different story.
The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC)—a UN-created body that monitors global hunger—declared a famine in Gaza in 2025.
But according to the IPC’s own methodology, a Phase 5 famine implies roughly two deaths per 10,000 people per day, while Phase 4 emergency conditions imply one death per 10,000 per day.
Based on the IPC’s classification—roughly 500,000 Gazans in Phase 5 and 1.07 million in Phase 4—those figures would imply more than 10,000 famine deaths between August 22 and October 7, 2025.
Hamas reported 461 malnutrition deaths during that entire period. That is a 95 percent shortfall compared with famine projections.
In other words, even Hamas’s own exaggerated statistics failed to support the famine narrative.
The Aid Israel Sent
Meanwhile, Israel was sending an average of 100 food trucks per day into Gaza through the Kerem Shalom crossing.
Historically, it is unheard of for a country to feed the population governed by an enemy it is actively fighting. Yet Israel continued sending food shipments throughout the war.
Once the trucks entered Gaza, distribution was handled by UN agencies. Often, the aid simply sat there.
By August 2025, video evidence showed nearly 950 trucks carrying roughly 2,500 tons of food sitting idle on the Gaza side of the crossing.
At the same time, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation—an organization established by the Trump administration—delivered roughly 100 million meals to Gazans by mid-2025, averaging 41 truckloads per day carrying more than two million meals.
At one point, the GHF publicly pleaded with the UN to allow it to distribute food that UN agencies themselves were not delivering.
But the UN—whose agencies maintain longstanding ties with Hamas—actively obstructed those efforts while pressuring humanitarian organizations not to cooperate with the GHF.
Zionism, the “Anti-Christian” Ideology
Another popular claim circulating through Tucker’s orbit is that Zionism is inherently anti-Christian.
Zionism is simply the belief that the Jewish people have the right to live in their ancestral homeland, Israel. Nowhere does Christian scripture deny such a right. In fact, the Apostle Paul—writing decades after becoming a follower of Jesus—reaffirms it. In Acts 13:17–19, he recounts how God “gave their land to His people as an inheritance,” underscoring the enduring biblical connection between the Jewish people and the land of Israel.
Yet Boller has repeatedly pushed the claim. Her activism eventually led to her removal from President Trump’s Religious Liberty Commission after she derailed a hearing on antisemitism by demanding that participants condemn Israel’s supposed “genocide.”
Senior Trump officials—many of them devout Christians—asked her repeatedly to stop spreading falsehoods. She refused. Instead, she hijacked discussions on antisemitism to defend Candace Owens, promote “Palestine,” and lecture participants about “Islamophobia.”
She was subsequently removed from the commission. Boller now claims she was fired for her religious beliefs.
If those beliefs consist of repeating Hamas propaganda, that is not Christianity.
The Third Temple Panic
The Woke Reich has also developed an odd theological panic about the Jewish hope for the Third Temple, saying it is “anti-Christian.”
Boller repeated the claim on Tucker’s show after Tucker himself previously declared the Third Temple “anathema” to Christianity. He even floated a theory that Israel supposedly started the Iran war in order to destroy the Al-Aqsa Mosque, blame Iran, and secretly build the Third Temple.
In reality, the Third Temple reflects a theological disagreement between Judaism and Christianity. Jews believe the Third Temple will be a future everlasting house of God on the Temple Mount. Christians believe Jesus himself represents the Third Temple. But even some Christians believe a physical Third Temple will be rebuilt before the Second Coming.
Either way, differences in theology do not make one religion “anathema” to another any more than they make Christianity inherently antisemitic—something Tucker and Boller repeatedly deny.
The Takeaway: Christianity Deserves Better Than This
Tucker Carlson, Carrie Prejean Boller, and their colleagues in the Woke Reich wrap themselves in the language of faith—“as Christians,” “in the name of Jesus,” “speaking truth”—while repeating patently false claims. They repeat casualty figures from Hamas as if they were gospel. They circulate stories that turn out to be false. They accuse Israel of famine and genocide despite evidence that directly contradicts those accusations.
For people who claim to speak on behalf of Jesus, their disregard for the truth is astonishing.
Sources
Tucker Carlson, Times of Israel, Times of Israel, New York Post, Henry Jackson Society, UN, World Health Organization, IDF, Times of Israel, CIA, JCFA, The Free Press, IPC, Honest Reporting, IDF, FDD, X, Israel National News, Daily Wire, Jewish Center for Justice, Acts 13, X, Tucker Carlson, Catholic Answers
